Fox advertised their shitty coverage of the BCS games with commercials depicting college football players running through a maze. The players had to avoid random obstacles and danger on their way to reaching the national trophy. While the commercial was typical Fox schlock aimed at the lowest common denomonator (see the NFL robot, continuous Ram truck ads) it was actually an apt depiction of the BCS ranking system.
Once again we are left to wonder who the best team in the nation is. The polls that consititute the BCS tell us Florida, but anyone who's watched any late season college football and bowl games would probably raise an eye brow if you told them that the Gators were the outright champion. If you saw USC play at the end of the season. Saw Utah beat up on Alabama. Even Texas squeeking by Ohio State... you have to wonder how those teams, or any other non-Big 10 team would stack up against Florida.
And that's the shit part. We're left to wonder. We're left with people's opinions and WOPR's statistical analyses to determine who #1 is. Coaches and players don't necessarily understand what they have to do to be highly ranked, but apparently running up the score is one way to do it. But does running up the score really indicate how good a team is? Or simply how much better they are than the team they're facing that day?
Until there is a true playoff system, we will never know who is truly the best team. I love college football, but I'm getting tired of lame championship games year after year that never wrap things up in a neat little bow. I'm tired of strength of schedule or losses having such an impact on the end result. I'm tired of hearing that extra games would be a burden on the student athletes who still practice daily during the month between the end of the season and the bowl games. And I'm tired of the BCS treating the Big 10 like a legitimate conference while leaving teams like Utah out because they're a non-BCS skool.
Until there's a true playoff, nothing will ever be answered. Questions will always remain. Sure there will be speculation of if X had faced Y instead of Z, things might have been different... but as long as one team makes it thru the bracket undefeated, it will remain speculation and not controversy. And there's a big difference there in my mind. And if you don't believe me, ask some people in Los Angeles, Salt Lake City, or Austin what they think about the BCS right now.
My guess is, not much.
The cream will never be allowed to rise the top as long as the pot is stirred.