Thursday, February 7, 2013

Sour Grapes and Bank of America


My wife spent most of the past two years unemployed.  (As you can tell, this is going to be a funny one...)  During that time we tried multiple times to lower our mortgage payments which usually ended up with a BoA rep flippantly telling us they can't help us.

Except the one time that they sent us to a third party collections agency to initiate the foreclosure process...  that really made us happy.

As my wife's prospects in the Chicago remained slim, we started looking at other places to live...  we ended up in Houston. (More on that in my new and growing as soon as I'm done bitching about Boa tumblr blog moved to houston.)  This means that something had to be done with the house.

We could walk away, but that's not in our nature...  so we're going to take a monthly loss on it...  hopefully minimized by renting it out.

Shortly before we moved a friend of a friend referred us to Rosie at Bank of America.  We thought we'd give it one more shot...  and holy shit...  this time they would work with us!

We weren't thrilled about staying with BoA, but other banks wouldn't even touch a house where the one next door was going for 1/4th of what we paid...  so we bit the bullet.

Things were good until last week, when I'm in the middle of moving, I get a poorly formatted, six page letter demanding we provide forms and documentation... and that we provide "detailed and satisfactory signed" letters explaining things like previous addresses or my wife's maiden name.

I call but get voice mail and leave a message in a tone that I would describe as bottled rage... and I decide that I'm just going to table this until after my 22 hour drive to Texas.

I finally connect with GJ (his initials) and it turns out, he not only knows his shit, he gives one too.  He went through the list of demands we were sent and it turns out we only need to provide the letters and a note from Citibank describing the terms of our HELOC...  5 of the six page to do list is for them.

I ask why his assistant sent me all of them and he didn't have a good answer, but he understood how overwhelming that appears to the customer and apologized.

Like I said, he knew and gave a shit.

So I get that handled, or so I thought until I got an email from Zulmalexa Irizarry who [somehow and inexplicably] goes by Mimi.

Hi scooneyisland,

I am taking over you (sic) loan since Rosie is no longer with Bank of America and need to have the following by end of day tomorrow:

1.       Letter of explanation signed and dated for address xx W xxTH ST xxx WESTMONT, IL xxxxx for H.
2.       Letter of explanation signed and dated for address for xx S xxTH ST MILWAUKEE, WI xxxxx yourself.
3.       Letter of explanation signed and dated on the following name variation: Looneyisland for yourself and on H for H. Just explain how each name is attached to each of you.
4.       Note for the 2nd mortgage with Citimortgage

Please contact as soon as you can at xxx-xxx-xxxx. I have tried to contact you but I can’t leave a message because your voicemail is not set up. The underwriter is only giving us until end of day tomorrow to get this documentation or the file will be cancelled. Please advise as soon as possible. Thank you.


Well...  that made my day. I sent an email expressing my disappointment and confusion.  

Hi Mimi,

I am very confused.  I am working with GJ on these issues so I am not sure why you are contacting me again about them as I have already satisfied nearly all of Bank of America's demands.

> GJ has the letters you are requesting.  

> The Note will not be available until our possessions are out of storage, GJ is aware of this as we spoke at length about it last week.

My voicemail is set up, GJ has been able to contact me and leave a voicemail...  as is everybody else.  Please make sure you are calling xxx-xxx-xxxx when you are trying to contact me, or xxx-xxx-xxxx if you are trying to contact H.

In the meantime, contact GJ (I CCed him on this email) to get these materials and if you have further questions.  I will place a follow up phone call to you to avoid any further confusion on your end, and so that you will have my phone number in your caller ID.


A little bitchy sure... but I feel she set the tone for the exchange, and she continued it when I made the call.  In the call she didn't apologize and got a bit argumentative when I mentioned that I didn't appreciate how we were being treated...  especially given our situation and BoA's track record.

Meanwile GJ emails Mimi and us separately that everything is handled and basically told her she was just mucking things up.  But we already knew that...  what we didn't know was the man who was CCed in the correspondence was Mimi's boss.

The wife and I talked if over that night and we came to the agreement that we would continue along the process despite wanting to give them the middle finger, but we don't want to work with Mimi.  So I sent this...

Mr. Man,

My wife and I are respectfully requesting that our loan application be assigned to someone else.  

We do not feel that Mimi Irizarry has our best interests in mind, nor do we have any confidence in her.  She waited 24 hours into a 48 hour period to make demands of us, didn't bother to find out that we had already handled these demands to the satisfaction of GJ, and claims that she tried to contact us when she did not.

While these things probably seem trivial and all part of daily business to you, this is just the latest in a long string of disappointing experiences with Bank of America over the past two years as we've tried to lower our payments after my wife was laid off.

It would be all too easy to walk away as we are in the middle of a move to Houston so my wife can be employed, but instead we're taking a monthly loss to do the right thing.

This loan is our last ditch effort and is very important to us, and we would appreciate it being handled by someone else.

We understand if our request is not possible, but her tone and actions indicate she doesn't value our continued business.  It's a shame that Rosie left, but we would prefer to work with someone more on her caliber instead of Mimi.

Thank you.

Mr. and Mrs. scooneyisland


And then this...

Mimi,

Yesterday you asked why we didn't appreciate the way we were being treated and GJ gives us a perfect example of good versus bad.  Compare his first sentence:

"I spoke to Mr. scooneyisland last week. I assured him I will try my level best to work with him during his difficult transition time."
With yours:

"I am taking over you loan (sic) since Rosie is no longer with Bank of America and need to have the following by end of day tomorrow:"

GJ treats us like customers in good standing since 2005, you treat us like another folder dropped on your desk after Rosie left.

Speaking of Rosie, she was the first person at Bank of America in the past two years who was actually willing to help us during our hardship.

Did you know that my wife had been unemployed for the better part of two years?

Did you know that our attempts to lower our payments were repeatedly rebuffed by Bank of America as we tried to deal with lower income?

Did you know that our last attempt to lower our payments ended up with Bank of America sending our information to a collections agency to begin foreclosure which is Not what we wanted?

Did you know that we had to move to Houston, TX at our own expense so that my wife could find a job?

Do you care that we are trying to do the right thing by not just walking away and letting the house go into foreclosure by renting it out and taking a monthly loss on the property?

This is our last ditch effort to do the right thing...  Rosie understood that.  GJ took to the time to understand that.

You simply send an email making demands of things that we have already dealt with.  And on top of it, you stated on the phone that the underwriter gave you 48 hours notice, yet you gave us barely over 24 hours.

You will probably claim that the short notice is because you tried to reach me by phone, but my voice mail isn't set up.  The facts are, my call history shows no call from the xxx area code all week, and my voice mail is set up.  Rosie, GJ, and seemingly everyone else in the world is able to reach me at xxx-xxx-xxxx and leave voice mails except for you.

That's just a weak excuse to us...  And just another example of the treatment I referred to...  only magnified by the professionalism and customer service shown by GJ.  He is the Only reason we are continuing on this process.

Despite what you think, we still have options.  One is shopping for another bank today, and another is to walk away from the house and save ourselves the headaches.

Regardless, we have asked your boss to have our application reassigned to someone more on the level of Rosie or GJ to handle the process from this point on.  After your email and patronizing tone during our phone call yesterday, we do not believe you have our best interests in mind and would prefer to work with someone else.

- Mr. and Mrs. scooneyisland

Bitchy?  Yup.  Vidictive?  Certainly.

Do I feel better and am I more than a little bit proud of these letters?

F Yes.


But in the end...  I just think that people need to be called out a bit.  I'm sure they're having a good laugh over this at the BoA office.  It's probably made the rounds and one of them has probably put my letter on the FaceSpace or the readdits...  

"Look at the time the crazy person spent writing an email!"

Thing is...  despite what I tell my manager, I write fast...  and it was worth  the 20 minutes to write and revise them.

F you Bank of America.  F you very much.